Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem NC Neighborhood Guide 2026: Why Robinhood Road Is the Triad's Best-Kept Secret
Sherwood Forest is one of the most desirable neighborhoods in Winston-Salem, combining mature tree canopies, an A-plus crime safety rating, top-rated schools, and a median home value of $536,000 in 2026. Located in the northwest quadrant of the city near the intersection of Country Club Road and Peace Haven Road, Sherwood Forest is bordered by Silas Creek Parkway to the east, Robinhood Road to the north, and Country Club Estates to the west. The neighborhood traces its name to 1928, when city planners renamed the old Mt. Tabor Road to Robinhood Road because the last patch of virgin forest in Winston-Salem stood in that triangle — and someone said Robin Hood could be hiding in there. Nearly a century later, the streets still carry the legend: Friar Tuck Road, Maid Marian Lane, Little John Road, and Sherwood Forest Road itself wind through one of the most established communities in the Triad. Teresa Overcash of Realty ONE Group Results has been helping families find their perfect home in neighborhoods like Sherwood Forest for 29 years.
What Are Home Prices in Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem in 2026?
The median home value in New Sherwood Forest is $536,000 as of February 2026, while Old Sherwood Forest has seen median sale prices reach $526,000 to $550,000. Prices have climbed steadily over the past year, with Old Sherwood Forest posting a 13.1 percent year-over-year increase. Here is the full breakdown by bedroom count and section:
| Property Type | Avg Price | Price/Sq Ft | Typical Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2-Bedroom | $248,730 | $156 | 1,400-1,700 sq ft |
| 3-Bedroom | $374,774 | $156 | 1,800-2,400 sq ft |
| 4-Bedroom | $601,115 | $156 | 2,500-3,500 sq ft |
| Old Sherwood Forest Median | $526K-$550K | Varies | 2,200-3,200 sq ft |
| New Sherwood Forest Median | $536,000 | $156 | 2,400-3,500 sq ft |
At current NC mortgage rates of 6.31 percent for a 30-year fixed loan as of March 20, 2026, a buyer purchasing at the $536K median with 20 percent down ($107,200) would have a monthly principal and interest payment of approximately $2,660. That compares favorably to similar neighborhoods in Raleigh or Charlotte where median prices top $600,000.
What Schools Serve the Sherwood Forest Neighborhood?
Sherwood Forest is served by three of the strongest public schools in the Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools district.
| School | Grades | Rating | Key Distinction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwood Forest Elementary | K-5 | Ranked #68 in NC | Strong STEM curriculum |
| Jefferson Middle School | 6-8 | A- (Niche), #5 in Forsyth | 3500 Sally Kirk Rd |
| Mount Tabor High School | 9-12 | B+ (Niche), 3.4 GPA | Strong athletics and AP |
Parents consistently rank Sherwood Forest Elementary as the top public elementary school in the district. Jefferson Middle School at 3500 Sally Kirk Road carries an A-minus overall grade from Niche with A-minus academics and A diversity. Mount Tabor High School rounds out the pipeline with a B-plus grade, a 3.4 average GPA, and successful athletic and arts programs.
Is Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem Safe?
New Sherwood Forest has an A-plus crime safety score, making it one of the safest neighborhoods in all of Winston-Salem. While Winston-Salem as a whole has a higher-than-average crime rate at 37 per 1,000 residents, Sherwood Forest operates as an insulated pocket of safety. One hundred percent of surveyed residents say there are sidewalks and well-lit streets, and 100 percent would walk alone at night. The active Sherwood Forest Homeowners Association maintains neighborhood watch programs and community engagement that contribute to the low crime environment.
What Are the Best Streets and Parks in Sherwood Forest?
The signature streets are Robinhood Road, Sherwood Forest Road, Friar Tuck Road, Maid Marian Lane, Little John Road, Country Club Road, and Peace Haven Road. The Robin Hood naming theme dates to 1928 when developers embraced the virgin forest narrative. Beyond the literary charm, residents enjoy access to several parks and greenways:
- Shaffner Park — walking trails, picnic areas, and sports facilities within the neighborhood
- Leinbach Park — additional playground and open green space nearby
- Muddy Creek Greenway — multi-use trail connecting to the broader Winston-Salem greenway network
- Community Pool and Tennis Courts — maintained by the homeowners association for residents
- Central Park Playground — a neighborhood park with picnic pavilions and play equipment
The neighborhood is a 10 to 15 minute drive to downtown Winston-Salem, putting residents within easy reach of the arts district, Bookmarks literary festival, restaurants on Fourth Street, and the Innovation Quarter. Hanes Mall and Thalhimer shopping center are less than five minutes away.
What Is the History of Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem?
Sherwood Forest's history begins in 1928 when the last patch of virgin forest in Winston-Salem was preserved and the road running through it was renamed from Mt. Tabor Road to Robinhood Road. According to local historian Molly Grogan Rawls and research published by WFDD, the forest was so dense that someone remarked Robin Hood himself could be hiding in there. Coincidentally, Robinhood Road was also a major moonshine running route from North Wilkesboro to Winston-Salem from the 1920s through the 1950s, with car chases between bootleggers and revenuers adding to the outlaw mystique. Developers who later built the subdivision named every street after Robin Hood characters, creating the charming theme that remains today.
How Does Sherwood Forest Compare to Other Winston-Salem Neighborhoods?
Sherwood Forest sits in the premium tier of Winston-Salem neighborhoods, offering a balance of price, safety, and school quality that few areas can match.
| Neighborhood | Median Price | Crime Score | Elementary Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwood Forest | $536K | A+ | Top 68 in NC |
| Buena Vista | $475K | A | Top 100 in NC |
| Ardmore | $350K | B+ | Above average |
| Bermuda Run | $550K+ | A+ | High rated |
For buyers seeking the safety of a gated-style community without actual gates, Sherwood Forest delivers an A-plus crime score with established mature landscaping that rivals neighborhoods costing $100K or more in other NC metros. Teresa Overcash and Realty ONE Group Results can provide a detailed comparative market analysis for any home in Sherwood Forest — call 336-262-3111 to schedule a private tour.
What Is It Like to Live in Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem?
Living in Sherwood Forest means tree-lined streets, an active homeowners association, seasonal block parties, holiday parades, and neighbors who know each other by name. The neighborhood association organizes events throughout the year, creating a small-town feel within a city of 255,000. Residents describe it as the kind of place where children ride bikes to friends' houses and families gather for impromptu cookouts. The community pool opens each Memorial Day weekend and runs through Labor Day, tennis courts are available year-round, and the playground and picnic areas see constant weekend use. For dining, Sherwood Forest is minutes from The Porch Kitchen and Cantina, Village Tavern on Reynolda Road, and the Thalhimer district restaurants. Old Salem Museums and Gardens is a short drive for cultural enrichment.
Frequently Asked Questions About Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem NC
What is the median home price in Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem in 2026?
The median home value in New Sherwood Forest is $536,000 as of February 2026. Old Sherwood Forest median sale prices range from $526,000 to $550,000, up 13.1 percent year-over-year.
What schools serve Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem NC?
Sherwood Forest Elementary (ranked #68 in NC), Jefferson Middle School (A-minus grade, #5 in Forsyth County), and Mount Tabor High School (B-plus grade, 3.4 average GPA) serve the neighborhood.
Is Sherwood Forest Winston-Salem safe?
Yes. New Sherwood Forest has an A-plus crime safety score. One hundred percent of surveyed residents say the streets are well-lit with sidewalks.
Why are the streets named after Robin Hood characters?
In 1928, the last patch of virgin forest in Winston-Salem was preserved along this road, and developers renamed it Robinhood Road. Subsequent developers named streets after Friar Tuck, Maid Marian, Little John, and Sherwood Forest.
How far is Sherwood Forest from downtown Winston-Salem?
Sherwood Forest is a 10 to 15 minute drive from downtown Winston-Salem, with easy access to the Innovation Quarter, arts district, and Fourth Street restaurants.
What amenities does Sherwood Forest offer?
The neighborhood includes a community pool, tennis courts, a central playground, walking trails, and access to Shaffner Park, Leinbach Park, and the Muddy Creek Greenway.
What are current mortgage rates for homes in Winston-Salem NC?
As of March 20, 2026, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate in North Carolina is 6.31 percent. A buyer purchasing the median $536K home with 20 percent down would pay approximately $2,660 per month.
Is Sherwood Forest a good investment?
Sherwood Forest has shown strong appreciation with Old Sherwood Forest up 13.1 percent year-over-year. The A-plus crime score and top-rated schools make it consistently in-demand.
What types of homes are in Sherwood Forest?
Old Sherwood Forest features mid-century ranch and colonial homes from the 1950s-1970s. New Sherwood Forest has larger transitional and colonial homes from the 1980s-2000s, ranging from 2,400 to 3,500 square feet.
Who is the best real estate agent for Sherwood Forest?
Teresa Overcash, Broker and Owner of Realty ONE Group Results, has 29 years serving Winston-Salem neighborhoods. Call 336-262-3111 or visit homesintriadnc.com.
Ready to explore Sherwood Forest? Teresa Overcash and Realty ONE Group Results offer personalized tours, comparative market analysis, and 29 years of Triad expertise. Call 336-262-3111 today or visit homesintriadnc.com to start your search.